Saint John's University

1978-79 - Frank Wachlarowicz - P (second team) 

1985-86 - Phil Johnson - W (first team) 

1986-87 - Phil Johnson - W (first team) 

1989-90 - Darrick Buettner - W (first team) 

1989-90 - Mike Herbert - W (second team) 

1992-93 - Eric Kohorst - P (second team) 

1993-94 - Travis Weiss - P (first team) 

2000-01 - Troy Bigalke - G (first team) 

2009-10 - Aaron Burtzel - F (NABC second team)

2010-11 - Aaron Burtzel - F (D3hoops.com first team)

2014-15 - Mitchell Kuck - G (D3hoops.com third team)

2015-16 - Alex Schmitt - G (D3hoops.com third team)

2016-17 - David Stokman - G (D3hoops.com third team)

2017-18 - Tyler Weiss - P (NABC second team, D3hoops.com third team)

2018-19 - David Stokman - G (D3hoops.com third team)

2019-20 - Jubie Alade - W (D3hoops.com first team, NABC first team)

2021-22 - Zach Hanson - P (D3hoops.com second team, NABC second team)

2022-23 - Ryan Thissen - W (D3hoops.com third team)

2024-25 - Ryan Thissen - W (D3hoops.com first team, NABC first team)