Saint John's University

Baseball
1997 (1) - Ryan Roder - 1B (ABCA first team) 
2007 (1) - Jay Kasner - 1B (ABCA third team)
2012 (1) - Joey Long - P (D3baseball.com second team)
2014 (1) - Justin Thompson - P (ABCA third team, D3baseball.com honorable mention)
2017 (1) - Wyatt Ulrich - OF (ABCA third team)
2021 (1) - Max Nyrop - DH (D3baseball.com first team)
2025 (1) - Joe Becker - 3B (D3baseball.com first team, ABCA second team)

Basketball
1953-54 (1) - Bill Sexton - G (NAIA third team)
1965-66 (1) - Joe Mucha - C (Tablet Catholic)
1977-78 (1) - Frank Wachlarowicz - F (NAIA third team)
1978-79 (1) - Frank Wachlarowicz - F (NAIA first team, AP second team)
2010-11 (1) - Aaron Burtzel - F (D3hoops.com honorable mention)
2024-25 (1) - Ryan Thissen - W (NABC second team)

Cross Country (top 40 at national meet; the top 25 were recognized through 1993, then top 35 from 1994-2016)
1968 (2) - Chuck Ceronsky (19th), John Cragg (29th)
1969 (1) - John Cragg (Second)
1970 (1) - John Cragg (Second; 21st at NCAA University Division)
1971 (1) - Joe Skaja (35th)
1973 (1) - Dave Lyndgaard (22nd)
1978 (1) - Joe Metzger (31st)
1982 (1) - Bob Morris (17th)
1983 (2) - Brian Smith (Third), John Gathje (Sixth)
1984 (2) - John Gathje (Eighth), Charlie Mahler (15th)
1985 (1) - Jim Gathje (19th)
1987 (2) - Pickle Gillach (23rd), Joe Bohlke (30th)
1988 (1) - Joe Bohlke (24th)
1994 (1) - Mike Brennan (18th)
1996 (1) - Ryan Steines (32nd)
1997 (1) - Brad Bauer (30th)
1998 (1) - John Krueger (Third)
1999 (2) - John Krueger (13th), Chet Boom (32nd)
2006 (1) - Kelly Fermoyle (28th)
2007 (1) - Chris Erichsen (Third)
2022 (1) - Lloyd Young (40th)

Football
1938 (1) - Edward Callanan - HB (AP)
1939 (1) - Jim Roche - HB (AP)
1945 (1) - Ken Schoener - E (AP)
1953 (3) - Bill Braun - OE (Tablet Catholic), Dick Coy - OT (Tablet Catholic), Casey Vilandre - HB (Tablet Catholic)
1954 (2) - Chuck Froehle - G (AP, Tablet Catholic, NAIA), Jim Lehman - HB (Tablet Catholic)
1955 (2) - Chuck Froehle - G (AP), Jim Lehman - HB (AP) 
1956 (1) - Chuck Froehle - G (AP)
1958 (3) - Duane Deutz - HB (Tablet Catholic), Roger Ludwig - OT (AP, Tablet Catholic), Sev Youso - OT (Tablet Catholic) 
1959 (1) - Felix Mannella - OG (Tablet Catholic)
1960 (2) - Gene Kramer - OE (Tablet Catholic), Tom O’Reilly - OE (Tablet Catholic)
1961 (4) - Bob Gavin - OG (Tablet Catholic Honorable Mention), Fred Philipson - OT (Tablet Catholic), Bob Stolz - OT (Tablet Catholic), Tom Wagner - FB (Tablet Catholic)
1962 (6) - John McDowell - OT (Tablet Catholic Honorable Mention), Tom McIntyre - OT (Tablet Catholic), Craig Muyres - QB (Tablet Catholic), Ken Roering - OE (Tablet Catholic), Bob Spinner - HB (Tablet Catholic Honorable Mention), Bill Wagner - C (Tablet Catholic)
1963 (4) - Bernie Beckman - DB/HB (NAIA, Tablet Catholic), Dave Honer - OG (Tablet Catholic), John McDowell - DT/OT (AP, NAIA, Tablet Catholic), Ken Roering - E (Tablet Catholic)
1964 (6) - Michael Collins - OT/DT (Tablet Catholic Honorable Mention), Fred Cremer - OT (Tablet Catholic), Rich Froehle - FB (Tablet Catholic), Jack Hickey - OC (Tablet Catholic), Paul Labinski - OG (Tablet Catholic Honorable Mention), Hardy Reyerson - E (Tablet Catholic)
1965 (5) - Michael Collins - OT/DT (Tablet Catholic), Fred Cremer - OT (AP, NAIA, Tablet Catholic), Tom Gillham - QB (Tablet Catholic), Dave Griffin - E (Tablet Catholic), Pat Whalin - DB (AP First Team, NAIA)
1966 (1) - Fred Cremer - OT (NAIA)
1973 (1) - Lyle Mathiasen - OL (NAIA)
1977 (2) - Jeff Norman - QB (AP Honorable Mention), Tim Schmitz - FB (AP First Team) 
1978 (1) - Ernie England - DL (NAIA)
1979 (1) - Ernie England - DL (AP First Team, Kodak, NAIA, UPI)
1981 (1) - Joe Kiley - DE (AP Second Team)
1982 (4) - Rick Bell - RB (AFCA, Kodak, NAIA First Team), Steve Cummings - LB (NAIA Honorable Mention), John Sowada - OL (NAIA Honorable Mention), Chuck Williams - DB (NAIA Honorable Mention)
1983 (3) - Chris Biggins - TE (Kodak, NAIA Honorable Mention), Jeff Chalmers - OL (Kodak, NAIA Honorable Mention), Roman George - DL (NAIA Honorable Mention)
1987 (1) - Bill Kauffmann - DB (Pizza Hut Second Team)
1988 (1) - Dan Grant - TE (Pizza Hut First Team)
1991 (3) - Pat Mayew - QB (Football Gazette First Team, Kodak), Steve O’Toole - DL (Football Gazette Second Team), Jay Conzemius - RB (Football Gazette Honorable Mention)
1992 (2) - Burt Chamberlin - OL (Champion U.S.A. Honorable Mention), Greg Thoma - DB (Champion U.S.A. Second Team)
1993 (5) - Burt Chamberlin - OL (AP Second Team, Champion U.S.A. First Team, Kodak), Tony Lesch - KR (Champion U.S.A. Third Team), Matt Malmberg - FB (Champion U.S.A. Second Team), Willie Seiler - QB (AP Third Team, Champion U.S.A. Second Team), Jim Wagner - DL (Champion U.S.A. First Team)
1994 (5) - Brian Kohorst - DL (College SID Third Team), Jeremy Loretz - WR (College SID Honorable Mention), Matt Malmberg - RB (College SID Honorable Mention, Football Gazette Third Team), Chris Palmer - RS (College SID Second Team, Football Gazette Honorable Mention), Jim Wagner - DL (AFCA)
1995 (2) - Chris Palmer - WR (American Football Quarterly First Team, Football Gazette First Team, HP Second Team), Jesse Redepenning - OL (Football Gazette Third Team, HP Second Team)
1996 (2) - Brett Mushatt - DB (American Football Quarterly First Team, HP Second Team), Jesse Redepenning - OL (American Football Quarterly First Team, HP Second Team) 
1997 (1) - Matt Griffith - DL (HP Second Team, Football Gazette Third Team) 
1998 (3) - Phil Barry - P (Football Gazette Third Team), Joe Kaczrowski - DL (Football Gazette Second Team), Brandon Novak - LB (Football Gazette First Team, HP Second Team) 
1999 (3) - Phil Barry - P (AFCA, D3football.com First Team, Football Gazette Second Team, HP Second Team), Beau LaBore - LB (D3football.com Second Team), Brandon Novak - LB (Football Gazette First Team, HP First Team, D3football.com Third Team)
2000 (6) - Nate Kirschner - TE (Football Gazette First Team, HP First Team, USAfootball.com Second Team), Beau LaBore - LB (D3football.com Second Team, HP Third Team, USAfootball.com Third Team), Tom Linnemann - QB (USAfootball.com Second Team, Football Gazette Honorable Mention, HP Honorable Mention), Chris Moore - RB (USAfootball.com Honorable Mention), Chris Salvato - OL (AFCA, AP Second Team, Football Gazette First Team, USAfootball.com First Team, D3football.com Second Team), Alex Wesley - DL (HP Third Team, USAfootball.com Honorable Mention) 
2001 (4) - Ryan Danielson - DL (HP Honorable Mention), Blake Elliott - WR (D3football.com Second Team), Jeremy Hood - DE (D3football.com First Team, HP First Team, Football Gazette Second Team), Cam McCambridge - LB (HP Honorable Mention)
2002 (5) - Blake Elliott - WR/RS (D3football.com First Team, Football Gazette First Team, HP First Team), Jeremy Hood - DE (D3football.com First Team, Football Gazette Second Team, HP Third Team), Dan Kosel - OL (Football Gazette Second Team, HP Third Team), Cam McCambridge - LB (D3football.com First Team, HP Second Team), Jason Pflipsen - DB (D3football.com Second Team, HP Second Team, Football Gazette Third Team)
2003 (5) - Justin Cass - OG (Football Gazette Second Team), Blake Elliott - WR (AP, AFCA, College SID First Team, D3football.com First Team, Football Gazette First Team), Jeremy Hood - DE (D3football.com First Team, Football Gazette Second Team, College SID Third Team), Cam McCambridge - LB (College SID Second Team, D3football.com Third Team, Football Gazette Third Team), Ryan Weinandt - DL (D3football.com Third Team, College SID Honorable Mention)
2004 (1) - Jason Good - DL (D3football.com Second Team, Football Gazette Third Team)
2005 (2) - Damien Dumonceaux - DL (AP, AFCA, D3football.com First Team, Football Gazette First Team), Matt Nelson - OL (Football Gazette Honorable Mention)
2006 (2) - Nick Gunderson - DL (D3football.com Honorable Mention), Kevin McNamara - DL (D3football.com Third Team)
2007 (2) - Nick Gunderson - DL (D3football.com Second Team), Andrew Salvato - OL (D3football.com Honorable Mention)
2009 (2) - Kyle Schroeder - DL (D3football.com Third Team), Ryan Wimmer - LB (AFCA First Team)
2010 (1) - Kyle Schroeder - DL (D3football.com First Team)
2011 (1) - Bobby Fischer - DB (BSN First Team)
2012 (2) - Bobby Fischer - DB (D3football.com First Team, BSN Second Team), Jimmie Mattson - K (D3football.com Fourth Team)
2014 (2) - Ross Carlson - OL (D3football.com Honorable Mention), Sam Sura - RB (D3football.com First Team)
2015 (4) - Josh Bungum - RET (D3football.com Honorable Mention), Carter Hanson - LB (D3football.com Honorable Mention), Sam Sura - RB (D3football.com Third Team), Peyton Thiry - DL (D3football.com Honorable Mention)
2016 (2) - Ben Eli - OL (AFCA First Team), Carter Hanson - LB (AP First Team, D3football.com Third Team)
2017 (2) - Dan Greenheck - OL (D3football.com Third Team), Max Jackson - DB (D3football.com Honorable Mention)
2018 (6) - Tommy Auger - TE (AFCA Second Team), Nathan Brinker - DL (AP Second Team, D3football.com Third Team), Jackson Erdmann - QB (AFCA First Team, AP First Team, D3football.com First Team), Will Gillach - WR (AP First Team, AFCA Second Team, D3football.com Second Team), Dan Greenheck - OL (AP First Team, D3football.com First Team, AFCA Second Team), Max Jackson - DB (AP First Team, D3football.com First Team)
2019 (7) - Ravi Alston - WR (AP Second Team), Ben Bartch - OL (AP Second Team, D3football.com First Team), Jackson Erdmann (AFCA First Team, AP Second Team, D3football.com Second Team), Dan Greenheck - OL (AP First Team, D3football.com Second Team), Chris Harris - CB (D3football.com Honorable Mention), Danny Pietruszewski - DL/LB (AP Second Team), J.W. Windsor - DL (D3football.com Second Team)
2021 (4) - Ravi Alston - WR (AFCA Second Team, AP Second Team, D3football.com Third Team), Alex Larson - TE (D3football.com Fourth Team), Nick Neumann - OL (AP Second Team), Michael Wozniak - DL (D3football.com First Team)
2022 (3) - Metoriah Faoliu - DL (D3football.com Fourth Team), Alex Larson - TE (AFCA First Team, AP First Team, D3football.com First Team), Michael Wozniak - DL (AFCA Second Team, AP Second Team, D3football.com Third Team)
2023 (2) - Joe Jaeger - OL (D3football.com Third Team), Alex Larson - TE (AFCA First Team, AP First Team, D3football.com First Team)
2024 (5) - Zach Frank - DL (D3football.com Fourth Team), Joey Gendreau - TE (D3football.com Fourth Team), Nick McKenzie - OL (D3football.com Fourth Team), Aaron Syverson - QB (AFCA Second Team, AP Second Team, D3football.com Second Team, Walter Camp), Dylan Wheeler - WR (AFCA First Team, AP First Team, D3football.com Third Team, Walter Camp)

Golf (GCAA)
1999-00 (2) - Matt McGovern (third team), Sammy Schmitz (third team)
2000-01 (2) - Sammy Schmitz (third team), Robert Cliff (honorable mention)
2001-02 (2) - Sammy Schmitz (second team), Nathan Proshek (honorable mention)
2002-03 (2) - Nathan Proshek (first team), Sammy Schmitz (second team)
2003-04 (1) - Josh Sherlin (second team)
2004-05 (2) - Josh Sherlin (first team), Andrew Longbella (third team) 
2006-07 (2) - Clinton Dammann (first team), Andrew Longbella (first team)
2007-08 (4) - Joe Schoolmeesters (first team), Matt Bohlig (second team), Joe Daly (third team), Joey Polingo (third team)
2008-09 (1) - Joe Schoolmeesters (third team)
2009-10 (3) - Mark Giorgi (second team), Ben Vangsness (second team), Tony Krogen (third team)
2010-11 (1) - Dennis Granath (first team)
2011-12 (1) - Dennis Granath (third team)
2012-13 (3) - Casey Vangsness (first team), Dennis Granath (third team), Drew Lynch (third team)
2013-14 (2) - Tommy Koehler (honorable mention), Casey Vangsness (honorable mention)
2014-15 (1) - Ryan Gallagher (honorable mention)
2016-17 (1) - Ryan Gallagher (honorable mention)
2017-18 (1) - Sam Olson (honorable mention)
2018-19 (1) - David Schneider (honorable mention)
2019-20 (1) - David Schneider (honorable mention)
2022-23 (1) - Sam Berger (honorable mention)

Hockey
1977-78 (1) - Bob Hanson - G (NAIA)
1978-79 (2) - Bob Hanson - G (NAIA), Dick Gunderson - D (AHCA)
1981-82 (1) - Pat Conlin - F (NAIA)
1986-87 (1) - Andy Clark - D (AHCA second team)
1997-98 (2) - Tryg Sarsland - D (AHCA first team), Matt Erredge - F (AHCA second team) 
1998-99 (1) - Matt Erredge - F (AHCA second team)
2001-02 (1) - Mike Possin - F (AHCA first team)
2002-03 (2) - Rick Gregory - G (AHCA second team), Ryan Langenbrunner - F (AHCA second team)
2003-04 (5) - Scott Bjorklund - F (AHCA first team), Darryl Smoleroff - D (AHCA first team), Adam Hanna - G (AHCA second team), Adam Holmgren - D (AHCA second team), Kevin Willey - F (AHCA second team)
2004-05 (3) - Adam Hanna - G (AHCA first team), Darryl Smoleroff - D (AHCA first team), Scott Bjorklund - F (AHCA second team)
2005-06 (3) - Adam Hanna - G (AHCA first team), Scott Bjorklund - F (AHCA second team), Darryl Smoleroff - D (AHCA second team)
2012-13 (1) - Saxton Soley - G (AHCA second team)
2021-22 (1) - Mac Berglove - G (AHCA second team)

Soccer
1976 (1) - Pat Lilly - D
1977 (1) - Mike Lilly - F 
1982 (1) - Terry Leiendecker - GK 

Swimming & Diving (top 16 at national meet)
1978 (8) - Jon Habben (10th, 50-yard freestyle), Jon Habben (11th, 100-yard freestyle), Jon Habben (12th, 400-yard freestyle relay), Greg Krenik (12th, 400-yard freestyle relay), Steve Remole (Fifth, 3-meter dive), Mike Salchert (12th, 400-yard freestyle relay), Mark Schwietz (12th, 400-yard freestyle relay), Mark Tracy (12th, 400-yard freestyle relay)
1979 (2) - Jim Connor (Third, 100-yard freestyle), Jim Connor (Seventh, 50-yard freestyle)
1980 (2) - Jim Connor (Eighth, 100-yard freestyle), Steve Remole (Fifth, 3-meter dive)
1981 (2) - Dean Roll (11th, 3-meter dive), Dan Williams (11th, 400-yard individual medley)
1982 (1) - John Hessburg (Seventh, 50-yard freestyle)
1983 (7) - Tom Duxbury (11th, 400-yard freestyle relay), John Hessburg (10th, 50-yard freestyle), John Hessburg (11th, 400-yard freestyle relay), Tom Kubinski (Sixth, 50-yard freestyle), Tom Kubinski (11th, 400-yard freestyle relay), Dean Roll (Eighth, 3-meter dive), Tom Thompson (11th, 400-yard freestyle relay)
1984 (2) - Tom Kubinski (Eighth, 50-yard freestyle), Dean Roll (11th, 1-meter dive)
1986 (11) - Chris Barta (Fourth, 100-yard backstroke), Chris Barta (10th, 400-yard medley relay), Pat Beskar (10th, 400-yard medley relay), Paul Eure (14th, 500-yard freestyle), Tom Kubinski (Seventh, 400-yard freestyle relay), Tom Kubinski (Eighth, 50-yard freestyle), Tom Kubinski (10th, 400-yard medley relay), Doug Lawrence (Seventh, 400-yard freestyle relay), Matt Lawrence (Seventh, 400-yard freestyle relay), Matt Lawrence (10th, 400-yard medley relay), Chris Stuart (Seventh, 400-yard freestyle relay)
1987 (7) - Chris Barta (Fourth, 100-yard backstroke), Chris Barta (Ninth, 200-yard backstroke), Chris Barta (12th, 400-yard medley relay), Pat Beskar (12th, 400-yard medley relay), Pat Beskar (12th, 200-yard breaststroke), Matt Lawrence (12th, 400-yard medley relay), John Newhouse (12th, 400-yard medley relay)
1988 (23) - Chris Barta (Fourth, 200-yard backstroke), Chris Barta (10th, 100-yard backstroke), Chris Barta (11th, 400-yard medley relay), Chris Barta (15th, 200-yard medley relay), Pat Beskar (10th, 200-yard freestyle relay), Pat Beskar (11th, 400-yard medley relay), Pat Beskar (15th, 200-yard medley relay), Eric Boyer (10th, 1-meter dive), James Casey (10th, 400-yard freestyle relay), Paul DeMorett (14th, 800-yard freestyle relay), Ken Krull (10th, 200-yard freestyle relay), Ken Krull (10th, 400-yard freestyle relay), Ken Krull (11th, 400-yard medley relay), Ken Krull (14th, 800-yard freestyle relay), Ken Krull (15th, 200-yard medley relay), Mark Lange (10th, 200-yard freestyle relay), Mark Lange (10th, 400-yard freestyle relay), Mark Lange (15th, 200-yard medley relay), Matt Lawrence (10th, 400-yard freestyle relay), Matt Lawrence (14th, 800-yard freestyle relay), John Newhouse (11th, 400-yard medley relay), John Newhouse (14th, 800-yard freestyle relay), Rob Schmidt (10th, 200-yard freestyle relay)
1989 (9) - James Casey (Fifth, 200-yard freestyle relay), James Casey (Sixth, 400-yard freestyle relay), John Deters (12th, 3-meter dive), Chad Kelly (Fifth, 200-yard freestyle relay), Chad Kelly (Sixth, 400-yard freestyle relay), Ken Krull (Fifth, 200-yard freestyle relay), Ken Krull (Sixth, 400-yard freestyle relay), Mark Lange (Fifth, 200-yard freestyle relay), Mark Lange (Sixth, 400-yard freestyle relay)
1990 (23) - Mark Biscan (15th, 400-yard medley relay), Eric Boyer (Seventh, 1-meter dive), James Casey (14th, 200-yard freestyle relay), James Casey (14th, 800-yard freestyle relay), James Casey (15th, 200-yard medley relay), James Casey (15th, 400-yard freestyle relay), James Casey (15th, 400-yard medley relay), John Deters (Second, 3-meter dive), John Deters (Third, 1-meter dive), Chad Kelly (14th, 200-yard freestyle relay), Chad Kelly (14th, 800-yard freestyle relay), Chad Kelly (15th, 200-yard medley relay), Chad Kelly (15th, 400-yard freestyle relay), Ken Krull (14th, 200-yard freestyle relay), Ken Krull (14th, 800-yard freestyle relay), Ken Krull (15th, 200-yard medley relay), Ken Krull (15th, 400-yard freestyle relay), Ken Krull (15th, 400-yard medley relay), Lee Prinkkila (14th, 800-yard freestyle relay), Mike Simonet (14th, 200-yard freestyle relay), Mike Simonet (15th, 200-yard medley relay), Mike Simonet (15th, 400-yard freestyle relay), Mike Simonet (15th, 400-yard medley relay)
1991 (3) - Bret Beecher (Seventh, 1-meter dive), John Deters (National Champion, 1-meter dive), John Deters (Fifth, 3-meter dive)
1992 (2) - John Deters (Fifth, 3-meter dive), John Deters (Eighth, 1-meter dive)
1994 (1) - Phil Steger (11th, 400-yard individual medley)
1995 (2) - Pat Underhill (11th, 50-yard freestyle), Pat Underhill (12th, 100-yard butterfly)
1996 (22) - Jake Bastien (10th, 200-yard medley relay), Jake Bastien (15th, 800-yard freestyle relay), Kris Bowman (10th, 200-yard medley relay), Kris Bowman (14th, 400-yard medley relay), Mark Schmitz (Seventh, 400-yard freestyle relay), Mark Schmitz (11th, 200-yard freestyle relay), Mark Schmitz (14th, 400-yard medley relay), Mark Schmitz (15th, 800-yard freestyle relay), Phil Steger (Seventh, 400-yard freestyle relay), Phil Steger (15th, 800-yard freestyle relay), Carl Stevens (11th, 200-yard freestyle relay), Pat Underhill (Seventh, 400-yard freestyle relay), Pat Underhill (10th, 200-yard medley relay), Pat Underhill (11th, 200-yard freestyle relay), Pat Underhill (14th, 400-yard medley relay), Pat Underhill (15th, 800-yard freestyle relay), Matt Zelen (Second, 100-yard freestyle), Matt Zelen (Seventh, 400-yard freestyle relay), Matt Zelen (10th, 200-yard medley relay), Matt Zelen (11th, 200-yard freestyle relay), Matt Zelen (12th, 50-yard freestyle), Matt Zelen (14th, 400-yard medley relay)
1997 (1) - Matt Zelen (Sixth, 100-yard butterfly)
1998 (3) - Matt Zelen (Fourth, 100-yard butterfly), Matt Zelen (Fourth, 100-yard freestyle), Matt Zelen (Seventh, 50-yard freestyle)
1999 (3) - Matt Zelen (National Champion, 50-yard freestyle), Matt Zelen (Second, 100-yard butterfly), Matt Zelen (Third, 100-yard freestyle)
2002 (12) - Jim Arnold (Sixth, 200-yard freestyle relay), Jim Arnold (Ninth, 200-yard medley relay), Jim Arnold (10th, 400-yard freestyle relay, Aaron Bidle (Sixth, 200-yard freestyle relay), Luke Vestrum (Sixth, 200-yard freestyle relay), Luke Vestrum (Ninth, 200-yard medley relay), Luke Vestrum (10th, 400-yard freestyle relay), Chris Waldorf (Sixth, 200-yard freestyle relay), Chris Waldorf (Ninth, 200-yard medley relay), Chris Waldorf (10th, 400-yard freestyle relay), David Williams (Ninth, 200-yard medley relay), David Williams (10th, 400-yard freestyle relay)
2003 (4) - Jim Arnold (Eighth, 50-yard freestyle), Jim Arnold (Eighth, 100-yard freestyle), Jim Arnold (16th, 200-yard freestyle), Luke Prokop (14th, 200-yard breaststroke)
2004 (2) - Luke Prokop (11th, 200-yard breaststroke), Luke Prokop (13th, 100-yard breaststroke)
2005 (14) - Joey Chapman (13th, 200-yard freestyle relay), Joey Chapman (15th, 400-yard medley relay), Joey Chapman (16th, 400-yard freestyle relay), Sam Christianson (13th, 200-yard freestyle relay), Sam Christianson (16th, 400-yard freestyle relay), Kerry O’Neill (13th, 200-yard freestyle relay), Kerry O’Neill (15th, 400-yard medley relay), Kerry O’Neill (16th, 400-yard freestyle relay), Luke Prokop (Third, 200-yard breaststroke), Luke Prokop (13th, 100-yard breaststroke), Luke Prokop (15th, 400-yard medley relay), David Williams (13th, 200-yard freestyle relay), David Williams (15th, 400-yard medley relay), David Williams (16th, 400-yard freestyle relay)
2011 (6) - Mando Moss (15th, 800-yard freestyle relay), Ty Nimens (15th, 800-yard freestyle relay), Wes Schlichting (14th, 3-meter dive), Wes Schlichting (16th, 1-meter dive), Josh Seaburg (15th, 800-yard freestyle relay), Michael Williams (15th, 800-yard freestyle relay)
2020 (1) - Jack Grabinski (CSCAA, Diving)
2021 (2) - Jack Grabinski (CSCAA, Diving), Connor Reed (CSCAA, Diving)
2025 (3) - Eli Grabinski (Eighth, 1-meter dive), Eli Grabinski (14th, 3-meter dive), Brayden Slavik (15th, 1,650-yard freestyle)

Tennis (ITA)
1989 (1) - Todd Schlorf (singles) 
1990 (1) - Todd Schlorf (singles)
1990 (2) - Todd Schlorf & Craig Herold (doubles)
1992 (1) - Ray Young (singles)
1993 (1) - Ray Young (singles)

Indoor Track & Field (top 8 at national meet)
1986 (1) - Dean Daninger (Sixth, shot put)
1987 (1) - Dean Daninger (Third, shot put)
1988 (2) - Dean Daninger (Fifth, shot put), Pat Jennrich (Fifth, 35-pound weight)
1999 (1) - Darwin Dumonceaux (Fourth, shot put)
2003 (1) - John Mathews (Fourth, 1,500 meters)
2004 (1) - Mike Marschel (Fifth, 800 meters)
2005 (1) - Paul Ferber (Eighth, triple jump)
2007 (1) - Chris Erichsen (Fourth, 5,000 meters)
2008 (2) - Eric Buss (Third, triple jump), Chris Erichsen (Sixth, 5,000 meters)
2009 (2) - Eric Buss (Third, triple jump), Erik Diley (Seventh, long jump)
2020* (5) - Drew Dockendorf (pole vault), Ryan Miller (60-meter dash), Maguire Petersen (high jump), Michael Wallace (triple jump), Collin Trout (triple jump)
2022 (1) - Maguire Petersen (Sixth, heptathlon)
2024 (1) - Kevin Arthur (second team; 15th, 60-meter dash)
2025 (4) - Max Lelwica (second team; Ninth, heptathlon), Jackson McDowell (Second, high jump), Zach Schaffer (second team; 16th, long jump), Anthony Thurk (second team; 14th, heptathlon)

*the USTFCCCA awarded All-America honors to all national qualifiers due to the COVID-19 pandemic and added second-team honors for individuals ninth-16th and relays (ninth and 10th) starting in 2024

Outdoor Track & Field (top 8 at national meet; top six through 1985)
1959 (1) - Jerry Schoenecker (Fifth, two mile; NAIA)
1960 (1) - Jerry Schoenecker (Third, steeplechase; NAIA)
1968 (2) - Jim Holmes (Fifth, high jump), Dave Lamm (Third, 200 meters; NAIA)
1969 (1) - John Cragg (Second, six mile; NAIA)
1970 (5) - Chuck Ceronsky (Second, steeplechase; NAIA), Chuck Ceronsky (Second, steeplechase), John Cragg (Second, six mile), Don Kluk (Sixth, 120-yard hurdles; NAIA), Don Kluk (Sixth, 120-yard hurdles)
1971 (2) - Don Kluk (Indoor: Fourth, 60-yard hurdles; NAIA), Don Kluk (Third, 120-yard hurdles)
1972 (4) - Mike Kremer (Fifth, steeplechase; NAIA), Mike Kremer (Fourth, steeplechase), Joe Skaja (Indoor: Fifth, two mile; NAIA), Joe Skaja (Third, 5,000 meters)
1974 (2) - Rudy Sawyer (Second, triple jump), Greg Traxler (Fifth, 440-yard hurdles)
1975 (1) - Mike Bauer (Fifth, 440-yard hurdles)
1978 (1) - Joe Perske (Fourth, marathon; NAIA)
1979 (2) - Nort Hatlie (Second, steeplechase), Joe Metzger (Second, 10,000 meters)
1980 (1) - Mike Frericks (Sixth, 400 meter hurdles)
1981 (2) - Mike Frericks (Fifth, 400 meter hurdles), Chuck Moorse (Sixth, 800 meters)
1982 (2) - Doug Clark (Sixth, steeplechase), Brian Smith (Second, 5,000 meters)
1983 (2) - Brian Smith (National Champion, 5,000 meters), John Sowada (Fourth, discus)
1984 (3) - Jim Gathje (Fourth, steeplechase), John Gathje (Fourth, 5,000 meters), Charlie Mahler (Seventh, 10,000 meters)
1985 (2) - Jim Gathje (National Champion, steeplechase), Charlie Mahler (Third, 5,000 meters)
1986 (2) - Jim Gathje (National Champion, steeplechase), Wade Weisz (Fourth, javelin)
1987 (2) - Joe Bohlke (Eighth, 10,000 meters), Dean Daninger (Fourth, shot put)
1988 (3) - Joe Bohlke (Sixth, 10,000 meters), Dean Daninger (Sixth, discus), Wade Weisz (Seventh, javelin)
1989 (1) - Kraig Runquist (Seventh, 1,500 meters)
1990 (2) - Scott Lindell (Fifth, steeplechase), Kraig Runquist (Fifth, 1,500 meters)
1994 (1) - Paul Chestovich (Eighth, 1,500 meters)
1995 (1) - Dan Besemann (Seventh, decathlon)
1996 (1) - Jeb Myers (Seventh, steeplechase)
1999 (3) - Darwin Dumonceaux (National Champion, shot put), John Guertin (Seventh, steeplechase), Steve Kimble (Sixth, decathlon)
2000 (1) - John Krueger (Third, 10,000 meters)
2003 (2) - Tom Engwall (Fourth, javelin), Mike Marschel (Sixth, 800 meters)
2004 (1) - Paul Ferber (Fifth, triple jump)
2006 (1) - Derek Johnson (Seventh, 400 meter hurdles)
2007 (5) - Eric Buss (Seventh, triple jump), Erik Diley (Fifth, long jump), Chris Erichsen (Second, steeplechase), Chris Erichsen (Fourth, 5,000 meters), Michael Leither (Second, 400-meter hurdles)
2008 (5) - Eric Buss (Seventh, triple jump), Erik Diley (Fifth, long jump), Chris Erichsen (Second, steeplechase), Chris Erichsen (Second, 5,000 meters), Kelly Fermoyle (Eighth, 10,000 meters)
2009 (3) - Eric Buss (Sixth, triple jump), Brayden Wagner (Sixth, decathlon), Brayden Wagner (Eighth, pole vault)
2013 (1) - Thomas Feichtinger (Eighth, 800 meters)
2016 (1) - Ryan Bugler (National Champion, steeplechase)
2017 (1) - Ryan Bugler (Fourth, steeplechase)
2019 (5) - Nick Gannon (National Champion, 4x100-meter relay), Brady Labine (National Champion, 4x100-meter relay), Ryan Miller (National Champion, 4x100-meter relay), Ryan Miller (Second, 100-meter dash), Drew Schoenbauer (National Champion, 4x100-meter relay)
2021 (8) - Kevin Arthur (Fourth, 4x100-meter relay), Drew Dockendorf (Sixth, pole vault), Brady Labine (Fourth, 4x100-meter relay), Ryan Miller (Third, 100-meter dash), Ryan Miller (Fourth, 4x100-meter relay), Maguire Petersen (T-Eighth, high jump), Shawn Schindler (Fourth, pole vault), Jack Young (Fourth, 4x100-meter relay)
2022 (2) - Brett Hague (Fourth, javelin), Maguire Petersen (Fifth, decathlon)
2023 (2) - Kevin Arthur (Seventh, 100-meter dash), Brett Hague (Seventh, javelin)
2024 (3) - Kevin Arthur (Fifth, 100-meter dash), Kevin Arthur (second team; 11th, 200-meter dash), Jackson McDowell (Eighth, high jump)
2025 (10) - Kevin Arthur (Second, 100-meter dash), Kevin Arthur (Second, 200-meter dash), Kevin Arthur (Third, 4x100-meter relay), Max Lelwica (Third, decathlon), Jackson McDowell (T-Third, high jump), Kieran Murnan (Third, 4x100-meter relay), Emanuel Popoca (Third, 4x100-meter relay), Max Reis (Third, 100-meter dash), Max Reis (Third, 4x100-meter relay), Max Reis (second team; Ninth, long jump)

*the USTFCCCA added All-America second-team honors for individuals ninth-16th and relays (ninth and 10th) starting in 2024

*Prior to 1973 the NCAA was divided into the University and College Divisions. Beginning in 1985, All-America honors were given to the top eight finishers at the NCAA III outdoor championship rather than the top six. SJU student-athletes who finished seventh or eighth prior to 1985 include - 1980: Chuck Moorse (Seventh, 800 meters), 1,600-meter relay team (Mike Frericks, Chris Longbella, Tom Frericks, Chuck Moorse); 1981: Bob Morris (Seventh, steeplechase); 1982: Bob Morris (Seventh, steeplechase); 1983: Jim Gathje (Eighth, steeplechase); and 1984: Charlie Mahler (Seventh, 10,000 meters).

Wrestling (top 8 at national meet)
1957-58 (2) - Larry Betzler (Fourth, 147 lbs.; NAIA), Gary Sauer (Third, 123 lbs.; NAIA)
1961-62 (1) - Ben Pulkrabek (Second, 190 lbs.; NAIA)
1970-71 (1) - Gary Svendsen (Fifth, 134 lbs.; NAIA)
1971-72 (2) - Tom Miller (Third, 190 lbs.; NAIA), Gary Svendsen (National Champion, 134 lbs.; NAIA)
1972-73 (1) - Tom Svendsen (Second, 134 lbs.; NAIA/Sixth, 134 lbs.; NCAA Division II)
1973-74 (1) - Tom Svendsen (Third, 134 lbs.; NAIA)
1978-79 (1) - Chris Meyer (Eighth, 134 lbs.)
1989-90 (2) - Scott Fernholz (Eighth, 142 lbs.), Tim Oelke (Eighth, 158 lbs.)
1992-93 (1) - Chris Grothe (Fifth, 190 lbs.)
1993-94 (1) - Rich Schneckenberger (Fifth, 167 lbs.)
1994-95 (2) - Rich Schneckenberger (Third, 158 lbs.), Dan Tschudi (Seventh, 142 lbs.)
1995-96 (2) - Andy Lien (Fifth, 177 lbs.), Matt Ryan (Fifth, 150 lbs.)
1996-97 (4) - John Newman (Third, 167 lbs.), Brandon Novak (Fifth, 190 lbs.), Matt Ryan (Eighth, 150 lbs.), Dan Tschudi (Seventh, 150 lbs.)
1997-98 (1) - Andy Lien (Third, 177 lbs.)
1998-99 (2) - John Newman (National Champion, 174 lbs.), Ryan Tietz (Fifth, 184 lbs.)
1999-00 (1) - Brandon Novak (Third, 197 lbs.)
2000-01 (1) - Brandon Novak (National Champion, 197 lbs.)
2001-02 (1) - Matt Vos (Third, 125 lbs.)
2003-04 (1) - Dan Fiecke (Fifth, 197 lbs.)
2005-06 (2) - Jacob Malone (Fourth, 157 lbs.), Dan Willaert (Seventh, 184 lbs.)
2006-07 (1) - Jacob Malone (Fifth, 157 lbs.)
2007-08 (1) - Mogi Baatar (Seventh, 125 lbs.)
2008-09 (2) - Dustin Baxter (Seventh, 184 lbs.), Minga Batsukh (National Champion, 141 lbs.)
2009-10 (1) - Minga Batsukh (National Champion, 141 lbs.)
2010-11 (5) - Matt Baarson (Fourth, 165 lbs.), Minga Batsukh (National Champion, 149 lbs.), Dustin Baxter (Third, 184 lbs.), Chad Henle (Seventh, 133 lbs.), Matt Pfarr (Seventh, 174 lbs.)
2011-12 (2) - Dustin Baxter (Second, 197 lbs.), Matt Pfarr (Fourth, 174 lbs.)
2012-13 (1) - Mitch Hagen (Fifth, 184 lbs.)
2019-20 (1) - Noah Becker (NWCA, 133 lbs.)