Saint John's University

*denotes Gagliardi Trophy recipient
^10 "finalists" were announced until 2010, when they current format of sending four finalists to the award presentation was adopted (now announced as 10 "semifinalists")
-13 semifinalists were selected in 2018
-12 semifinalists were selected in 2019
-15 semifinallists were selected in 2021 and 2022
-20 semifinalists were selected in 2023
-18 semifinalists were selected in 2024

1993
Frank Baker - RB (Chicago)
*Jim Ballard - QB (Mount Union)
Carey Bender - RB (Coe)
Chris Conkling - QB (Anderson)
Michael Flesch - OG (Thomas More)
John Janke - RB (Wisconsin-La Crosse)
Taver Johnson - LB (Wittenberg)
Marco Lainez - LB (Union)
Vic Moncato - WR/P/RET (Farleigh-Dickinson)
Willie Seiler - QB (Saint John's)

1994
Victor Ameye - QB (Widener)
Paul Bell - QB (Allegheny)
*Carey Bender - RB (Coe)
Brad Hensley - QB (Kenyon)
Mark Kacmarynski - RB (Central)
Matt Malmberg - RB (Saint John's)
Vic Moncato - WR/P/RET (Farleigh-Dickinson)
Jason Richards - TE (Illinois Wesleyan)
Matt Szczypinski - DE (Washington & Jefferson)
Bobby Walker - LB (Williams)

1995
Craig Anderson - LB (Ohio Wesleyan)
Jason Baer - QB (Washington & Jefferson)
Robert Hull - DT (Washington and Lee)
Nathan Hutchings - WR (Eureka)
Anthony Jones - RB (La Verne)
Craig Kusick - QB (Wisconsin-La Crosse)
*Chris Palmer - WR (Saint John's)
Terry Peebles - QB (Hanover)
Jason Richards - TE (Illinois Wesleyan)
Rick Sanger - LB (Central)

1996
Craig Anderson - LB (Ohio Wesleyan)
Bill Borchert - QB (Mount Union)
Joe DeAngelis - OG (Trinity, Conn.)
*Lon Erickson - QB (Illinois Wesleyan)
James Jones - RB (Coast Guard)
Mark Kacmarynski - RB (Central)
Kyle Klein - QB (Albion)
Kurt Ramler - QB (Saint John's)
Nick Reiser - DE/LB (Allegheny)
Brandon Steinheim - RB (Wesley)

1997
*Bill Borchert - QB (Mount Union)
Michael Bramlage - FS/RET (Thomas More)
London Fletcher - LB (John Carroll)
Brandon Graham - RB (Hope)
Trey Holcomb - LB (Manchester)
Derrin Lamker - QB (Augsburg)
Derrick LeVake - OT (Wisconsin-Whitewater)
Greg Lister - QB (Rowan)
Jim Mormino - RB (Allegheny)
Kevin O'Donohue - LB (Hanover)

1998
R.J. Bowers - RB (Grove City)
Matt Bunyan - QB (Wisconsin-Stout)
Troy Dougherty - QB (Grinnell)
Krishaun Gilmore - RB (Rensselaer)
*Scott Hvistendahl - WR/P (Augsburg)
Thomas Lapato - DB (Western Maryland)
Guy Leman - RB (Simpson)
Scott Pingel - WR (Westminster)
Danny Ragsdale - QB (Redlands)
Chris Stormer - QB (Hanover)

1999
R.J. Bowers - RB (Grove City)
Michael Burton - QB (Trinity, Texas)
Matt LeFever - QB (Western Connecticut State)
Martin Mood - TE (Frostburg State)
Kevin Otte - DB (Wilmington)
Matt Perceval - WR (Wesleyan, Conn.)
Scott Pingel - WR (Westminster)
*Danny Ragsdale - QB (Redlands)
Paul Smith - RB/KR (Gettysburg)
Ben Streby - WR (Otterbein)

2000 (only nine finalists)
Corbett Boone - S (Hardin-Simmons)
R.J. Bowers - RB (Grove City)
Anthony Casciano - DT (College of New Jersey)
Seth Duerr - LB (Wooster)
*Chad Johnson - QB (Pacific Lutheran)
Tom Linnemann - QB (Saint John's)
Adam Marino - WR (Mount Union)
Shane Ream - RB (Allegheny)
Jeff Sanger - LB (Central)

2001
Hans Bengston - S (Bethel)
Matt Capone - RB (Ohio Wesleyan)
Chris Czernek - QB (Cal Lutheran)
Shearrod Duncan - RB (Ursinus)
T.J. Hess - DB (Widener)
Chris Huff - LB (Rhodes)
Nathan Jackson - WR (Menlo)
Jerimiah Janssen - LB (St. Norbert)
*Chuck Moore - RB (Mount Union)
Joshua Stinehour - DE (Union)

2002
Jeremy Boyce - RB (Trinity, Texas)
Ed Cracchiolo - RB (Farleigh-Dickinson)
Blake Elliott - WR/RET (Saint John's)
Andrew Hilliard - WR (St. Thomas)
Dan Pincelli - QB (Hartwick)
*Dan Pugh - RB (Mount Union)
Jamie Spielman - LB (Wisconsin-Stout)
Chris Sullivan - RB (Washington and Lee)
Craig Swanson - QB (Hobart)
Steve Wilson - DE (King's)

2003
Mark Bartosic - WR (Susquehanna)
Mike Donnenwerth - QB/P (Simpson)
*Blake Elliott - WR/RET (Saint John's)
Cody Fredenburg - QB (Mary Hardin-Baylor)
Brad Keem - DE (St. John Fisher)
Scott Krause - QB (Wisconsin-Stevens Point)
Sam Lacy - S (Bethel)
Tyler Matthews - QB (Linfield)
Rocky Myers - S (Wesley)
Conrad Singh - WR (Hampden-Sydney)

2004
Zac Bruney - QB (Mount Union)
Scott Burnoski - WR (Wisconsin-La Crosse)
David Crowley - WR (Centre)
Nick Cushman - WR (Albright)
Lance Moore - RB (Hardin-Simmons)
Brad Musso - WR (Wheaton, Ill.)
*Rocky Myers - S (Wesley)
Anthony Sutton - RB (Wooster)
Daniel Swanstrom - QB (Rhodes)
Jordan Talge - CB (Concordia-Moorhead)

2005
Justin Beaver - RB (Wisconsin-Whitewater)
Ross Dillavou - DE (Loras)
Damien Dumonceaux - DT (Saint John's)
*Brett Elliott - QB (Linfield)
Russ Harbaugh - QB (Wabash)
Dusty Kain - WR (Simpson)
Adam Knoblauch - QB (Delaware Valley)
Doug Phillips - QB (John Carroll)
Joe Rizzo - DB (Washington, Mo.)
Mitch Tanney - QB (Monmouth, Ill.)

2006
Tom Arcidiacono - RB (Union)
*Josh Brehm - QB (Alma)
Thomas Brew - LB (Case Western Reserve)
Kirby Carr - LB (Bethel)
Adam Haas - DT (Cortland State)
Ryan Kleppe - DT (Wisconsin-Whitewater)
Kam Kniss - QB (North Central, Ill.)
Tristan Murray - RB (Wittenberg)
Jordan Neal - QB (Hardin-Simmons)
Chad Otte - S (Wilmington)

2007
*Justin Beaver - RB (Wisconsin-Whitewater)
Derek Blanchard - OG (Mount Union)
Jason Boltus - QB (Hartwick)
Thomas Brew - LB (Case Western Reserve)
Eric Dube - LB (Dickinson, Pa.)
Paul Keeley - QB (Alfred)
Alex Kofoed - QB (Saint John's)
Adrian Pynenberg - LB (Wabash)
Drew Smith - WR (Hampden-Sydney)
P.J. Theisen - WR (St. Thomas)

2008
Jordan Berg - QB (Augsburg)
Jason Boltus - QB (Hartwick)
Justin Feaster - QB (Hardin-Simmons)
Juan Joseph - QB (Millsaps)
*Greg Micheli - QB (Mount Union)
Jack Rafferty - QB (Otterbein)
Chad Rupp - QB (Franklin)
Dominic Sulo - RB (North Central, Ill.)
Bobby Swallow - QB (Washington & Jefferson)
Dan Whalen - QB (Case Western Reserve)

2009
Gerry (Spud) Dick - QB (DePauw)
Judd Lutz - LB (Mount Union)
Dave Paveletz - RB (Susquehanna)
John Peters - LB (Union)
Jeff Schebler - K (Wisconsin-Whitewater)
Adam Shaffer - QB (Mississippi College)
Alex Tanney - QB (Monmouth, Ill.)
*Blaine Westemeyer - OT (Augustana, Ill.)
Dan Whalen - QB (Case Western Reserve)
David Zachary - RB (Central)

2010
Quincy Daniels - RB (Mary Hardin-Baylor)
Shea Dwyer - RB (Wesleyan, Conn.)
Justin Feaster - QB (Hardin-Simmons)
Matt Hoffman - DE (Rowan)
Zachary Homyk - WR (Case Western Reserve)
Ben McLaughlin - QB (Louisiana College)
Kyle Ray - QB (Franklin)
Aaron Rusch - WR (Wisconsin-Whitewater)
Ben Wartman - RB (St. Thomas)
*Eric Watt - QB (Trine)

2011
Matt Blanchard - QB (Wisconsin-Whitewater)
Peter Bulandr - DT (North Central, Ill.)
Alex Ferrara - S (Mount Union)
Chris Haupt - QB (Widener)
Dan Pitcher - QB (Cortland State)
Alex Tanney - QB (Monmouth, Ill.)
Alex Thiry - QB (St. Scholastica)
Hewitt Tomlin - QB (Johns Hopkins)
Fritz Waldvogel - WR/RET (St. Thomas)
*Michael Zweifel - WR (Dubuque)

2012
Zach Autenrieb - DB (Thomas More)
Nick Driskill - S (Mount Union)
McCallum Foote - QB (Middlebury)
Wyatt Hanus - QB (Dubuque)
Luke Heinsohn RB/K (Washington and Lee)
Curtis James - OC (St. Thomas)
Noah Joseph - LB (Union)
Craig Sykes - LB (Heidelberg)
Nathan Wara - QB (Wisconsin-Oshkosh)
*Scottie Williams - RB (Elmhurst)

2013
*Kevin Burke - QB (Mount Union)
Graham Craig - QB (LaGrange)
Austin Damaschke - QB (Concordia, Wis.)
McCallum Foote - QB (Middlebury)
Cole Klotz - LB (Wisconsin-Whitewater)
Kyle Linville - WR (Franklin)
Octavias McKoy - RB (Western Connecticut State)
Adham Talaat - DE (Gallaudet)
Keith Welch, Jr. - QB (Lewis & Clark)
Erik Westerberg - LB (Augustana, Ill.)

2014
Michael Bates - QB (Illinois College)
*Kevin Burke - QB (Mount Union)
Joe Callahan - QB (Wesley)
Brady Grayvold - CB (Wisconsin-Whitewater)
Domonique Hayden - RB (Thomas More)
Dylan Jones - RB (Willamette)
Matt Pawlowski - QB (Guilford)
Logan Schrader - QB (Wartburg)
Sam Sura - RB - RB (Saint John's)
Josh Warbington - QB (East Texas Baptist

2015
*Joe Callahan - QB (Wesley)
Alex Kocheff - S (Mount Union)
Kodie McNamara - LB (Gettysburg)
Matt Pawlowski - QB (Guilford)
Jessie Ramos - WR/KR (Hardin-Simmons)
Logan Schrader - QB (Wartburg)
David Simmet - OT (St. Thomas)
Matt Snebold - OT (Wheaton, Ill.)
Sam Sura - RB (Saint John's)

2016
Matt Barnes - LB (Monmouth)
John Flood - DL (Wisconsin-Whitewater)
*Carter Hanson - LB (Saint John's)
Trevor Heitland - RB (Coe)
A.J. LiCata - LB (Alfred)
Baylor Mullins - S/P (Mary Hardin-Baylor)
Sam Riddle - QB (Linfield)
J.J. Tomlin - QB (Washington, Mo.)
Cory Ward - LB (Hardin-Simmons)
Dayton Winn - RB/RET (Hendrix)

2017
Austin Breunig - RB (North Central)
Matt Gono - OL (Wesley)
Nick Holcomb - WR (Wisconsin-La Crosse)
*Brett Kasper - QB (Wisconsin-Oshkosh)
Ty Parsons - LB (East Texas Baptist)
Matt Sacia - QB (Wartburg)
John Smith - RB (Husson)
Jordan Wilcox - FB (Springfield)
Evan Wyse - QB (Trine)
Jesse Zubik - WR (Washington & Jefferson)

2018
Hayden Bauserman - QB (Shenandoah)
Lamar Carswell - RB (Trine)
Reese Childress - WR/P (Hardin-Simmons)
*Jackson Erdmann - QB (Saint John's)
Canaan Gebele - QB (Denison)
Joe Germinerio - QB (Brockport State)
Nick Giorgio - DE (Springfield)
Harry Henschler - DE (Wisconsin-Whitewater)
LeAnthony Reasnover - RB (Eureka)
Danny Robinson - LB (Mount Union)
Broc Rutter - QB (North Central)
Matt Sacia - QB (Wartburg)
Eric Stevenson - LB (Wheaton, Ill.)

2019
Jackson Erdmann - QB (Saint John's)
Joe Germinerio - QB (Ithaca)
Jaquan Hemphill - RB (Hardin-Simmons)
Joey Longoria - DT (Mary Hardin-Baylor)
Alex Minton - RB (Denison)
Mason Opple - QB (Hope)
Josh Parks - RB (St. Thomas)
*Broc Rutter - QB (North Central)
Robert Shufford - RB (Birmingham-Southern)
Wyatt Smith - QB (Linfield)
Cole Spieker - WR (Wisconsin-La Crosse)
Gavin Zimbelman - QB (Aurora)

2021
Ian Blankenship - QB (U.S. Merchant Marine)
Jefferson Fritz - DB/P/RET (Mary Hardin-Baylor)
Cody Gustafson - WR (Grove City)
*Blaine Hawkins - QB (Central)
Michael Hnatkowsky - QB (Muhlenberg)
Tucker Horn - QB (Trinity, Texas)
Tyler Jarnagin - QB (Benedictine)
Kyle Jones - QB (Hardin-Simmons)
Andrew Kamienski - WR (North Central)
Max Meylor - QB (Wisconsin-Whitewater)
Braxton Plunk - QB (Mount Union)
Jaran Roste - QB (Bethel)
Brees Segala - QB (Cortland State)
Wyatt Smith - QB (Linfield)
Gavin Zimbelman - QB (Aurora)

2022
Will Bowers - QB (Wheaton, Ill.)
*Ethan Greenfield - RB (North Central, Ill.)
Kyle King - QB/P (Mary Hardin-Baylor)
Evan Lewandowski - QB (Wisconsin-Whtiewater)
Jon Lewis - RB (Birmingham-Southern)
Phil Lutz - WR (Tufts)
Jon Murray Jr. - RB (Baldwin Wallace)
Michael Nobile - DL (Delaware Valley)
Nate Palmer - WR (Utica)
Braxton Plunk - QB (Mount Union)
Jaran Roste - QB (Bethel)
Joey Stutzman - RB (Wisconsin-La Crosse)
Boomer Warren - OL (Hardin-Simmons)
A.J. Winfield - QB (Ithaca)
Michael Wozniak - DL (Saint John's)

2023
Kaleb Blaha - QB (Wisconsin-River Falls)
Justin Blazek - DL (Wisconsin-Platteville)
Kolbe Blunt - RB (Belhaven)
Zac Boyes - QB (Cortland State)
Jake Breitbach - WR (Gustavus Adolphus)
Brandon Cade - RB (Berry)
Drew Campanale - QB (Randolph-Macon)
Destin Chance - QB (Illinois College)
Robert Coury - LB (Carnegie Mellon)
Owen Grover - LB (Wartburg)
Egon Hein - DB (Wisconsin-Whitewater)
Keyser Helterbrand - QB (Wisconsin-La Crosse)
Tucker Horn - QB (Trinity, Texas)
Tomas Kenary - DL (Middlebury)
*Luke Lehnen - QB (North Central, Ill.)
Braxton Plunk - QB (Mount Union)
Luke Schuermann - DL (Johns Hopkins)
Aaron Syverson - QB (Saint John's)
Josh Taylor - QB (Mount St. Joseph)
Giovanni Weeks - RB (Wheaton, Ill.)

2024
Brody Bantolina - RB (Pacific)
Zac Boyes - QB (Cortland State)
Destin Chance - QB (Illinois College)
Robert Coury - LB (Carnegie Mellon)
Josh Ehrlich - QB (Susquehanna)
A.J. Jackson - RB/KR/WR (Lake Forest)
Matt Jung - DB (Bethel)
*Luke Lehnen - QB (North Central, Ill.)
Jacquez Mabin - DL (Delaware Valley)
Nathan McCahill - QB (DePauw)
Charlie Patterson - LB (Hardin-Simmons)
Jacob Pugh - QB (Washington & Jefferson)
Diamontie Quinn - RB (Curry)
Dante Aviles Santos - QB (Umass-Dartmouth)
Arsen Shtefan - RB (Springfield)
Brandt Stare - WR (Wisconsin-Platteville)
Jack Studer - WR (Wisconsin-La Crosse)
Aaron Syverson - QB (Saint John's)

  *denotes Gagliardi Trophy recipient

Albion (Mich.)
1996 - Kyle Klein - QB

Albright (Pa.)
2004 - Nick Cushman - WR

Alfred (N.Y.)
2007 - Paul Keeley - QB
2016 - A.J. LiCata - LB

Allegheny (Pa.)
1994 - Paul Bell - QB 
1996 - Nick Reiser - DE/LB
1997 - Jim Mormino - RB
2000 - Shane Ream - RB

Alma (Mich.)
2006 - Josh Brehm - QB*

Anderson (Ind.)
1993 - Chris Conkling - QB

Augsburg (Minn.)
1997 - Derrin Lamker - QB
1998 - Scott Hvistendahl - WR*
2008 - Jordan Berg - QB

Augustana (Ill.)
2009 - Blaine Westemeyer - OT*
2013 - Erik Westerberg - LB

Aurora (Ill.)
2019 - Gavin Zimbelman - QB
2021 - Gavin Zimbelman - QB

Baldwin Wallace (Ohio)
2022 - Jon Murray Jr. - RB

Belhaven (Miss.)
2023 - Kolbe Blunt - RB

Benedictine (Ill.)
2021 - Tyler Jarnagin - QB

Berry (Ga.)
2023 - Brandon Cade - RB

Bethel (Minn.)
2001 - Hans Bengston - S
2003 - Sam Lacy - S
2006 - Kirby Carr - LB
2021 - Jaran Roste - QB
2022 - Jaran Roste - QB
2024 - Matt Jung - DB

Birmingham-Southern (Ala.)
2019 - Robert Shufford - RB
2022 - Jon Lewis - RB

Brockport State (N.Y.)
2018 - Joe Germinerio - QB

California Lutheran
2001 - Chris Czernek - QB

Carnegie Mellon (Pa.)
2023 - Robert Coury - LB
2024 - Robert Coury - LB

Case Western Reserve (Ohio)
2006 - Thomas Brew - LB
2007 - Thomas Brew - LB
2008 - Dan Whalen - QB
2009 - Dan Whalen - QB
2010 - Zachary Homyk - WR

Central (Iowa)
1994 - Mark Kacmarynski - RB
1995 - Rick Sanger - LB
1996 - Mark Kacmarynski - RB
2000 - Jeff Sanger - LB
2009 - David Zachary - RB
2021 - Blaine Hawkins - QB*

Centre (Ky.)
2004 - David Crowley - WR

Chicago (Ill.)
1993 - Frank Baker - RB

Coast Guard (Conn.)
1996 - James Jones - RB

Coe (Iowa)
1993 - Carey Bender - RB
1994 - Carey Bender - RB*
2016 - Trevor Heitland - RB

Concordia (Wis.)
2013 - Austin Damaschke - QB

Concordia-Moorhead (Minn.)
2004 - Jordan Talge - CB

Cortland State (N.Y.)
2006 - Adam Haas - DT
2011 - Dan Pitcher - QB
2021 - Brees Segala - QB
2023 - Zac Boyes - QB
2024 - Zac Boyes - QB

Curry (Mass.)
2024  - Diamontie Quinn - RB

Delaware Valley (Pa.)
2005 - Adam Knoblauch - QB
2022 - Michael Nobile - DL
2024 - Jacquez Mabin - DL

Denison (Ohio)
2018 - Canaan Gebele - QB
2019 - Alex Minton - RB

DePauw (Ind.)
2009 - Gerry (Spud) Dick - QB
2024 - Nathan McCahill - QB

Dickinson (Pa.)
2007 - Eric Dube - LB

Dubuque (Iowa)
2011 - Michael Zweifel - WR*
2012 - Wyatt Hanus - QB

East Texas Baptist
2014 - Josh Warbington - QB
2017 - Ty Parsons - LB

Elmhurst (Ill.)
2012 - Scottie Williams - RB*

Eureka (Ill.)
1995 - Nathan Hutchings - WR
2018 - LeAnthony Reasnover - RB

Farleigh-Dickinson (N.J.)
1993 - Vic Moncato - WR/RET
1994 - Vic Moncato - WR/RET
2002 - Ed Cracchiolo - RB

Franklin (Ind.)
2008 - Chad Rupp - QB
2010 - Kyle Ray - QB
2013 - Kyle Linville - WR

Frostburg State (Md.)
1999 - Martin Mood - TE

Gallaudet (D.C.)
2013 - Adham Talaat - DE

Gettysburg (Pa.)
1999 - Paul Smith - RB/KR
2015 - Kodie McNamara - LB

Grinnell (Iowa)
1998 - Troy Dougherty - QB

Grove City (Pa.)
1998 - R.J. Bowers - RB
1999 - R.J. Bowers - RB
2000 - R.J. Bowers - RB
2021 - Cody Gustafson - WR

Guilford (N.C.)
2014 - Matt Pawlowski - QB
2015 - Matt Pawlowski - QB

Gustavus Adolphus (Minn.)
2023 - Jake Breitbach - WR

Hampden-Sydney (Va.)
2003 - Conrad Singh - WR
2007 - Drew Smith - WR

Hanover (Ind.)
1995 - Terry Peebles - QB
1997 - Kevin O'Donohue - LB
1998 - Chris Stormer - QB

Hardin-Simmons (Texas)
2000 - Corbett Boone - S
2004 - Lance Moore - RB
2006 - Jordan Neal - QB
2008 - Justin Feaster - QB
2010 - Justin Feaster - QB
2015 - Jessie Ramos - WR/KR
2016 - Cory Ward - LB
2018 - Reese Childress - WR/P
2019 - Jaquan Hemphill - RB
2021 - Kyle Jones - QB
2022 - Boomer Warren - OL
2024 - Charlie Patterson - LB

Hartwick (N.Y.)
2002 - Dan Pincelli - QB
2007 - Jason Boltus - QB
2008 - Jason Boltus - QB

Heidelberg (Ohio)
2012 - Craig Sykes - LB

Hendrix (Ark.)
2015 - Dayton Winn - RB/RET
2016 - Dayton Winn - RB/RET

Hobart (N.Y.)
2002 - Craig Swanson - QB

Hope (Mich.)
1997 - Brandon Graham - RB
2019 - Mason Opple - QB

Husson (Maine)
2017 - John Smith - RB

Illinois College
2014 - Michael Bates - QB
2023 - Destin Chance - QB
2024 - Destin Chance - QB

Illinois Wesleyan
1994 - Jason Richards - TE
1995 - Jason Richards - TE
1996 - Lon Erickson - QB*

Ithaca (N.Y.)
2019 - Joe Germinerio - QB
2022 - A.J. Winfield - QB

John Carroll (Ohio)
1997 - London Fletcher - LB
2005 - Doug Phillips - QB

Johns Hopkins (Md.)
2011 - Hewitt Tomlin - QB
2023 - Luke Schuermann - DL

Kenyon (Ohio)
1994 - Brad Hensley - QB

King's (Pa.)
2002 - Steven Wilson - DE

LaGrange (Ga.)
2013 - Graham Craig - QB

Lake Forest (Ill.)
2024 - A.J. Jackson - RB/KR/WR

La Verne (Calif.)
1995 - Anthony Jones - RB

Lewis & Clark (Ore.)
2013 - Keith Welch, Jr. - QB

Linfield (Ore.)
2003 - Tyler Matthews - QB
2005 - Brett Elliott - QB*
2016 - Sam Riddle - QB
2019 - Wyatt Smith - QB
2021 - Wyatt Smith - QB

Loras (Iowa)
2005 - Ross Dillavou - DE

Louisiana College
2010 - Ben McLaughlin - QB

Manchester (Ind.)
1997 - Trey Holcomb - LB

Mary Hardin-Baylor (Texas)
2003 - Cody Fredenburg - QB
2010 - Quincy Daniels - RB
2016 - Baylor Mullins - S/P
2019 - Joey Longoria - DT
2021 - Jefferson Fritz - DB/P/RET
2022 - Kyle King - QB/P

Umas-Dartmouth
2024 - Dante Aviles Santos - QB

Menlo (Calif.)
2001 - Nathan Jackson - WR

Middlebury (Vt.)
2012 - McCallum Foote - QB
2013 - McCallum Foote - QB
2023 - Tomas Kenary - DL

Millsaps (Miss.)
2008 - Juan Joseph - QB

Mississippi College
2009 - Adam Shaffer - QB

Monmouth (Ill.)
2005 - Mitch Tanney - QB
2009 - Alex Tanney - QB
2011 - Alex Tanney - QB
2016 - Matt Barnes - LB

Mount St. Joseh (Ohio)
2023 - Josh Taylor - QB

Mount Union (Ohio)
1993 - Jim Ballard - QB*
1996 - Bill Borchert - QB
1997 - Bill Borchert - QB*
2000 - Adam Marino - WR
2001 - Chuck Moore - RB*
2002 - Dan Pugh - RB*
2004 - Zac Bruney - QB
2007 - Derek Blanchard - OG
2008 - Greg Micheli - QB*
2009 - Judd Lutz - LB
2011 - Alex Ferrara - S
2012 - Nick Driskill - S
2013 - Kevin Burke - QB*
2014 - Kevin Burke - QB*
2015 - Alex Kocheff - S
2018 - Danny Robinson - LB
2021 - Braxton Plunk - QB
2022 - Braxton Plunk - QB
2023 - Braxton Plunk - QB

Muhlenberg (Pa.)
2021 - Michael Hnatkowsky - QB

The College of New Jersey
2000 - Anthony Casciano - DT

North Central (Ill.)
2006 - Kam Kniss - QB
2008 - Dominic Sulo - RB
2011 - Peter Bulandr - DT
2017 - Austin Breunig - RB
2018 - Broc Rutter - QB
2019 - Broc Rutter - QB*
2021 - Andrew Kamienski - WR
2022 - Ethan Greenfield - RB*
2023 - Luke Lehnen - QB*
2024 - Luke Lehnen - QB*

Ohio Wesleyan
1995 - Craig Anderson - LB
1996 - Craig Anderson - LB
2001 - Matt Capone - RB

Otterbein (Ohio)
1999 - Ben Streby - WR
2008 - Jack Rafferty - QB

Pacific (Ore.)
2024 - Brody Bantolina - RB

Pacific Lutheran (Wash.)
2000 - Chad Johnson - QB*

Randolph-Macon (Va.)
2023 - Drew Campanale - QB

Redlands (Calif.)
1998 - Danny Ragsdale - QB
1999 - Danny Ragsdale - QB*

Rensselaer (N.Y.)
1998 - Krishaun Gilmore - RB

Rhodes (Tenn.)
2001 - Chris Huff - LB
2004 - Daniel Swanstrom - QB

Rowan (N.J.)
1997 - Greg Lister - QB
2010 - Matt Hoffman - DE

Saint John's (Minn.)
1993 - Willie Seiler - QB 
1994 - Matt Malmberg - RB 
1995 - Chris Palmer - WR*
1996 - Kurt Ramler - QB 
2000 - Tom Linnemann - QB 
2002 - Blake Elliott - WR/RET 
2003 - Blake Elliott - WR/RET*
2005 - Damien Dumonceaux - DT
2007 - Alex Kofoed - QB
2014 - Sam Sura - RB
2015 - Sam Sura - RB
2016 - Carter Hanson - LB*
2018 - Jackson Erdmann - QB*
2019 - Jackson Erdmann - QB
2022 - Michael Wozniak - DL
2023 - Aaron Syverson - QB
2024 - Aaron Syverson - QB

St. John Fisher (N.Y.)
2003 - Brad Keem - DE

St. Norbert (Wis.)
2001 - Jerimiah Janssen - LB

St. Thomas (Minn.)
2002 - Andrew Hilliard - WR
2007 - P.J. Theisen - WR
2010 - Ben Wartman - RB
2011 - Fritz Waldvogel - WR/RET
2012 - Curtis James - OC
2015 - David Simmet - OT
2019 - Josh Parks - RB

St. Scholastica (Minn.)
2011 - Alex Thiry - QB

Shenandoah (Va.)
2018 - Hayden Bauserman - QB

Simpson (Iowa)
1998 - Guy Leman - RB
2003 - Mike Donnenwerth - QB/P
2005 - Dusty Kain - WR

Springfield (Mass.)
2017 - Jordan Wilcox - FB
2018 - Nick Giorgio - DE
2024 - Arsen Shtefan - RB

Susquehanna (Pa.)
2003 - Mark Bartosic - WR
2009 - Dave Paveletz - RB
2024 - Josh Ehrlich - QB

Thomas More (Ky.)
1993 - Michael Flesch - OG
1997 - Michael Bramlage - FS/RET
2012 - Zach Autenrieb - DB
2014 - Domonique Hayden - RB

Trine (Ind.)
2010 - Eric Watt - QB*
2017 - Evan Wyse - QB
2018 - Lamar Carswell - RB

Trinity (Conn.)
1996 - Joe DeAngelis - OG

Trinity (Texas)
1999 - Michael Burton - QB
2002 - Jeremy Boyce - RB
2021 - Tucker Horn - QB
2023 - Tucker Horn - QB

Tufts (Mass.)
2022 - Phil Lutz - WR

Union (N.Y.)
1993 - Marco Lainez - LB
2001 - Joshua Stinehour - DE
2006 - Tom Arcidiacono - RB
2009 - John Peters - LB
2012 - Noah Joseph - LB

U.S. Merchant Marine (N.Y.)
2021 - Ian Blankenship - QB

Ursinus (Pa.)
2001 - Shearrod Duncan - RB

Utica (N.Y.)
2022 - Nate Palmer - WR

Wabash (Ind.)
2005 - Russ Harbaugh - QB
2007 - Adrian Pynenberg - LB

Wartburg (Iowa)
2014 - Logan Schrader - QB
2015 - Logan Schrader - QB
2017 - Matt Sacia - QB
2018 - Matt Sacia - QB
2023 - Owen Grover - LB

Washington (Mo.)
2005 - Joe Rizzo - DB
2016 - J.J. Tomlin - QB

Washington & Jefferson (Pa.)
1994 - Matt Szczypinski - DE
1995 - Jason Baer - QB
2008 - Bobby Swallow - QB
2017 - Jesse Zubik - WR
2024 - Jacob Pugh - QB

Washington and Lee (Va.)
1995 - Robert Hull - DT
2002 - Chris Sullivan - RB
2012 - Luke Heinsohn - RB/K

Wesley (Del.)
1996 - Brandon Steinheim - RB
2003 - Rocky Myers - S
2004 - Rocky Myers - S*
2014 - Joe Callahan - QB
2015 - Joe Callahan - QB*
2017 - Matt Gono - OL

Wesleyan (Conn.)
1999 - Matt Perceval - WR
2010 - Shea Dwyer - RB

Western Connecticut State
1999 - Matt LeFever - QB
2013 - Octavias McKoy - RB

Western Maryland
1998 - Thomas Lapato - DB

Westminster (Mo.)
1998 - Scott Pingel - WR
1999 - Scott Pingel - WR

Wheaton (Ill.)
2004 - Brad Musso - WR
2015 - Matt Snebold - OT
2018 - Eric Stevenson - LB
2022 - Will Bowers - QB
2023 - Giovanni Weeks - RB

Widener (Pa.)
1994 - Victor Ameye - QB
2001 - T.J. Hess - DB
2011 - Chris Haupt - QB

Willamette (Ore.)
2014 - Dylan Jones - RB

Williams (Mass.)
1994 - Bobby Walker - LB

Wilmington (Ohio)
1999 - Kevin Otte - DB
2006 - Chad Otte - S

Wisconsin-La Crosse
1993 - John Janke - RB
1995 - Craig Kusick - QB
2004 - Scott Burnoski - WR
2017 - Nick Holcomb - WR
2019 - Cole Spieker - WR
2022 - Joey Stutzman - RB
2023 - Keyser Helterbrand - QB
2024 - Jack Studer - WR

Wisconsin-Oshkosh
2012 - Nathan Wara - QB
2017 - Brett Kasper - QB*

Wisconsin-Platteville
2023 - Justin Blazek - DL
2024 - Brandt Stare - WR

Wisconsin-River Falls
2023 - Kaleb Blaha - QB

Wisconsin-Stevens Point
2003 - Scott Krause - QB

Wisconsin-Stout
1998 - Matt Bunyan - QB
2002 - Jamie Spielman - LB

Wisconsin-Whitewater
1997 - Derrick LeVake - OT
2005 - Justin Beaver - RB
2006 - Ryan Kleppe - DT
2007 - Justin Beaver - RB*
2009 - Jeff Schebler - K
2010 - Aaron Rusch - WR
2011 - Matt Blanchard - QB
2013 - Cole Klotz - LB
2014 - Brady Grayvold - CB
2016 - John Flood - DL
2018 - Harry Henschler - DE
2021 - Max Meylor - QB
2022 - Evan Lewandowski - QB
2023 - Egon Hein - DB

Wittenberg (Ohio)
1993 - Taver Johnson - LB
2006 - Tristan Murray - RB

Wooster (Ohio)
2000 - Seth Duerr - LB
2004 - Anthony Sutton - RB