2024 - Luke Lehnen, QB, North Central College (Ill.)
2023 - Luke Lehnen, QB, North Central College (Ill.)
2022 - Ethan Greenfield, RB, North Central College (Ill.)
2021 - Blaine Hawkins, QB, Central College (Iowa)
2019 - Broc Rutter, QB, North Central College (Ill.) - Video
2018 - Jackson Erdmann, QB, Saint John's University (Minn.) - Video
2017 - Brett Kasper, QB, University of Wisconsin-Oshkosh - Video
2016 - Carter Hanson, LB, Saint John's University (Minn.) - Video
2015 - Joe Callahan, QB, Wesley College (Del.) - Video
2014 - Kevin Burke, QB, University of Mount Union (Ohio) - Video
2013 - Kevin Burke, QB, University of Mount Union (Ohio) - Video
2012 - Scottie Williams, RB, Elmhurst College (Ill.) - Video
2011 - Michael Zweifel, WR, University of Dubuque (Iowa) - Video
2010 - Eric Watt, QB, Trine University (Ind.) - Video
2009 - Blaine Westemeyer, OL, Augustana College (Ill.) - Video
2008 - Greg Micheli, QB, Mount Union College (Ohio) - Video
2007 - Justin Beaver, RB, University of Wisconsin-Whitewater - Video
2006 - Josh Brehm, QB, Alma College (Mich.) - Video
2005 - Brett Elliott, QB, Linfield College (Ore.)
2004 - Rocky Myers, SS, Wesley College (Del.)
2003 - Blake Elliott, WR/PR/KR, Saint John's University (Minn.)
2002 - Dan Pugh, RB, Mount Union College (Ohio)
2001 - Chuck Moore, RB, Mount Union College (Ohio)
2000 - Chad Johnson, QB, Pacific Lutheran University (Wash.)
1999 - Danny Ragsdale, QB, University of Redlands (Calif.)
1998 - Scott Hvistendahl, WR/P, Augsburg College (Minn.)
1997 - Bill Borchert, QB, Mount Union College (Ohio)
1996 - Lon Erickson, QB, Illinois Wesleyan University
1995 - Chris Palmer, WR, Saint John's University (Minn.)
1994 - Carey Bender, RB, Coe College (Iowa)
1993 - Jim Ballard, QB, Mount Union College (Ohio)
