(Top 40 at National Meet; the Top 25 were recognized through 1993, then Top 35 from 1994-2016)
1968 – Chuck Ceronsky (19th), John Cragg (29th)
1969 – John Cragg (Second)
1970 – John Cragg (Second; 21st at NCAA University Division)
1971 – Joe Skaja (35th)
1973 – Dave Lyndgaard (22nd)
1978 – Joe Metzger (31st)
1982 – Bob Morris (17th)
1983 – Brian Smith (Third), John Gathje (Sixth)
1984 – John Gathje (Eighth), Charlie Mahler (15th)
1985 – Jim Gathje (19th)
1987 – Pickle Gillach (23rd), Joe Bohlke (30th)
1988 – Joe Bohlke (24th)
1994 – Mike Brennan (18th)
1996 – Ryan Steines (32nd)
1997 – Brad Bauer (30th)
1998 – John Krueger (Third)
1999 – John Krueger (13th), Chet Boom (32nd)
2006 – Kelly Fermoyle (28th)
2007 – Chris Erichsen (Third)
2022 – Lloyd Young (40th)
Cross country All-Americans were awarded to the 25 through 1993 and then the top 35 from 1994-2016. 2017. Saint John's athletes who would have achieved All-America status include: Chuck Ceronsky, 1969, 26th; Nick Overby, 1973, 34th; Matt Larking, 1981, 36th; Charlie Mahler, 1982, 26th; Brian Smith, 1982, 35th; Scott Lindell, 1988, 36th; Kris Jungels, 1989, 36th; Dan Simmons, 1998, 40th; Nick Thoemke, 2000, 39th; and Dustin Franta, 2009, 37th.
