1957-58 (NAIA) - Larry Betzler (4th, 147 lbs.), Gary Sauer (3rd, 123 lbs.)
1961-62 (NAIA) - Ben Pulkrabek (2nd, 190 lbs.)
1970-71 (NAIA) - Gary Svendsen (5th, 134 lbs.)
1971-72 (NAIA) - Tom Miller (3rd, 190 lbs.), Gary Svendsen (National Champion, 134 lbs.)
1972-73 (NAIA) - Tom Svendsen (2nd, 134 lbs.; 6th, 134 lbs. in NCAA Division II)
1973-74 (NAIA) - Tom Svendsen (3rd, 134 lbs.)
1978-79 - Chris Meyer (8th, 134 lbs.)
1989-90 - Scott Fernholz (8th, 142 lbs.), Tim Oelke (8th, 158 lbs.)
1992-93 - Chris Grothe (5th, 190 lbs.)
1993-94 - Rich Schneckenberger (5th, 167 lbs.)
1994-95 - Rich Schneckenberger (3rd, 158 lbs.), Dan Tschudi (7th, 142 lbs.)
1995-96 - Andy Lien (5th, 177 lbs.), Matt Ryan (5th, 150 lbs.)
1996-97 - John Newman (3rd, 167 lbs.), Brandon Novak (5th, 190 lbs.), Matt Ryan (8th, 150 lbs.), Dan Tschudi (7th, 150 lbs.)
1997-98 - Andy Lien (3rd, 177 lbs.)
1998-99 - John Newman (National Champion, 174 lbs.), Ryan Tietz (5th, 184 lbs.)
1999-00 - Brandon Novak (3rd, 197 lbs.)
2000-01 - Brandon Novak (National Champion, 197 lbs.)
2001-02 - Matt Vos (3rd, 125 lbs.)
2003-04 - Dan Fiecke (5th, 197 lbs.)
2005-06 - Jacob Malone (4th, 157 lbs.), Dan Willaert (7th, 184 lbs.)
2006-07 - Jacob Malone (5th, 157 lbs.)
2007-08 - Mogi Baatar (7th, 125 lbs.)
2008-09 - Minga Batsukh (National Champion, 141 lbs.), Dustin Baxter (7th, 184 lbs.)
2009-10 - Minga Batsukh (National Champion, 141 lbs.)
2010-11 - Matt Baarson (4th, 165 lbs.), Minga Batsukh* (National Champion, 149 lbs.), Dustin Baxter (3rd, 184 lbs.), Chad Henle (7th, 133 lbs.), Matt Pfarr (7th, 174 lbs.)
2011-12 - Dustin Baxter (2nd, 197 lbs.), Matt Pfarr (4th, 174 lbs.)
2012-13 - Mitch Hagen (5th, 184 lbs.)
2019-20 - Noah Becker (NWCA, 133 lbs.)
*NCAA Championships' Outstanding Wrestler
